* [Feature Request] Support for sharing root-level files across repositories
@ 2025-09-26 8:33 George Ogden
2025-09-29 17:25 ` rsbecker
0 siblings, 1 reply; 4+ messages in thread
From: George Ogden @ 2025-09-26 8:33 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: git
Hello Git developers,
Firstly, apologies if this has already been discussed or if there is a
way to solve this problem that I am not aware of.
Motivation
Git submodules are very useful for sharing directories between
repositories. However, in some workflows, there is a need to share a
single file that must live in the repository root.
A concrete example is .pre-commit-config.yaml. I maintain a standard
template across many repositories. When I add a new hook or update a
version, I have to manually update the file in each repository. I
could use a submodule for this, but submodules always appear in a
subdirectory — not at the root where tools expect this file.
The same issue arises with other configuration files that need to
reside at the top level of a project (linters, CI configs, licenses,
etc.).
Proposal
It would be helpful if Git provided a way to share a file across
repositories so that it appears at the root of the working tree,
without requiring a separate build step, symlink, or copy operation.
I understand there are alternative approaches (subtrees, packages,
external tooling), but they all involve extra indirection. Having
first-class support within Git for this use case would make it much
simpler and more consistent.
Thanks
Thank you for your work maintaining and evolving Git! I would greatly
appreciate any feedback on whether this idea has been considered
before, and if there are technical reasons it may not fit Git’s model.
Best regards,
George Ogden
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 4+ messages in thread
* RE: [Feature Request] Support for sharing root-level files across repositories
2025-09-26 8:33 [Feature Request] Support for sharing root-level files across repositories George Ogden
@ 2025-09-29 17:25 ` rsbecker
2025-09-29 19:32 ` George Ogden
2025-09-29 21:17 ` Ben Knoble
0 siblings, 2 replies; 4+ messages in thread
From: rsbecker @ 2025-09-29 17:25 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: 'George Ogden', git
On September 26, 2025 4:33 AM, George Ogden wrote:
>Hello Git developers,
>
>Firstly, apologies if this has already been discussed or if there is a way to solve this
>problem that I am not aware of.
>
>Motivation
>
>Git submodules are very useful for sharing directories between repositories.
>However, in some workflows, there is a need to share a single file that must live in
>the repository root.
>
>A concrete example is .pre-commit-config.yaml. I maintain a standard template
>across many repositories. When I add a new hook or update a version, I have to
>manually update the file in each repository. I could use a submodule for this, but
>submodules always appear in a subdirectory — not at the root where tools expect
>this file.
>
>The same issue arises with other configuration files that need to reside at the top
>level of a project (linters, CI configs, licenses, etc.).
>
>Proposal
>
>It would be helpful if Git provided a way to share a file across repositories so that it
>appears at the root of the working tree, without requiring a separate build step,
>symlink, or copy operation.
>
>I understand there are alternative approaches (subtrees, packages, external
>tooling), but they all involve extra indirection. Having first-class support within Git
>for this use case would make it much simpler and more consistent.
>
>Thanks
>
>Thank you for your work maintaining and evolving Git! I would greatly appreciate
>any feedback on whether this idea has been considered before, and if there are
>technical reasons it may not fit Git’s model.
I have been thinking about a current use case for this RFE. Consider
GNU/Configure-based projects where we have config.guess and config.sub in the
repository root. These two files are independent of the project itself and truly
should be shared and managed from a single authoritative source. It can be a
real delay/pain to wait for the project to manually update these two files
from an upstream to get platform support for their project.
In order to support something like this, we might need a submodule concept
That supports something like a link upwards. Or this might be something
That could be part of the sparse-checkout infrastructure. I'm not sure, but I
Do think there is merit to this. It could also apply to organisations that have
cross-application root certificates that need to be in the same directory
as the application root.
Just my musings.
--Randall
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 4+ messages in thread
* Re: [Feature Request] Support for sharing root-level files across repositories
2025-09-29 17:25 ` rsbecker
@ 2025-09-29 19:32 ` George Ogden
2025-09-29 21:17 ` Ben Knoble
1 sibling, 0 replies; 4+ messages in thread
From: George Ogden @ 2025-09-29 19:32 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: rsbecker; +Cc: git
Hi Randall,
Thanks so much for your thoughtful reply. I agree that there would be
a lot of use cases beyond the one I initially mentioned.
I don’t have the technical background to suggest how this might best
fit into Git, but I’d be very interested to hear more from others on
the list about possible directions. My main motivation is simply to
make it easier to maintain a single shared file across multiple
repositories, without having to copy it around manually.
Thanks again for taking the time to engage with this idea. I really
appreciate it.
Best regards,
George
On Mon, 29 Sept 2025 at 19:25, <rsbecker@nexbridge•com> wrote:
>
> On September 26, 2025 4:33 AM, George Ogden wrote:
> >Hello Git developers,
> >
> >Firstly, apologies if this has already been discussed or if there is a way to solve this
> >problem that I am not aware of.
> >
> >Motivation
> >
> >Git submodules are very useful for sharing directories between repositories.
> >However, in some workflows, there is a need to share a single file that must live in
> >the repository root.
> >
> >A concrete example is .pre-commit-config.yaml. I maintain a standard template
> >across many repositories. When I add a new hook or update a version, I have to
> >manually update the file in each repository. I could use a submodule for this, but
> >submodules always appear in a subdirectory — not at the root where tools expect
> >this file.
> >
> >The same issue arises with other configuration files that need to reside at the top
> >level of a project (linters, CI configs, licenses, etc.).
> >
> >Proposal
> >
> >It would be helpful if Git provided a way to share a file across repositories so that it
> >appears at the root of the working tree, without requiring a separate build step,
> >symlink, or copy operation.
> >
> >I understand there are alternative approaches (subtrees, packages, external
> >tooling), but they all involve extra indirection. Having first-class support within Git
> >for this use case would make it much simpler and more consistent.
> >
> >Thanks
> >
> >Thank you for your work maintaining and evolving Git! I would greatly appreciate
> >any feedback on whether this idea has been considered before, and if there are
> >technical reasons it may not fit Git’s model.
>
> I have been thinking about a current use case for this RFE. Consider
> GNU/Configure-based projects where we have config.guess and config.sub in the
> repository root. These two files are independent of the project itself and truly
> should be shared and managed from a single authoritative source. It can be a
> real delay/pain to wait for the project to manually update these two files
> from an upstream to get platform support for their project.
>
> In order to support something like this, we might need a submodule concept
> That supports something like a link upwards. Or this might be something
> That could be part of the sparse-checkout infrastructure. I'm not sure, but I
> Do think there is merit to this. It could also apply to organisations that have
> cross-application root certificates that need to be in the same directory
> as the application root.
>
> Just my musings.
> --Randall
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 4+ messages in thread
* Re: [Feature Request] Support for sharing root-level files across repositories
2025-09-29 17:25 ` rsbecker
2025-09-29 19:32 ` George Ogden
@ 2025-09-29 21:17 ` Ben Knoble
1 sibling, 0 replies; 4+ messages in thread
From: Ben Knoble @ 2025-09-29 21:17 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: rsbecker; +Cc: George Ogden, git
> Le 29 sept. 2025 à 13:25, rsbecker@nexbridge•com a écrit :
>
> On September 26, 2025 4:33 AM, George Ogden wrote:
>> Hello Git developers,
>>
>> Firstly, apologies if this has already been discussed or if there is a way to solve this
>> problem that I am not aware of.
>>
>> Motivation
>>
>> Git submodules are very useful for sharing directories between repositories.
>> However, in some workflows, there is a need to share a single file that must live in
>> the repository root.
>>
>> A concrete example is .pre-commit-config.yaml. I maintain a standard template
>> across many repositories. When I add a new hook or update a version, I have to
>> manually update the file in each repository. I could use a submodule for this, but
>> submodules always appear in a subdirectory — not at the root where tools expect
>> this file.
>>
>> The same issue arises with other configuration files that need to reside at the top
>> level of a project (linters, CI configs, licenses, etc.).
>>
>> Proposal
>>
>> It would be helpful if Git provided a way to share a file across repositories so that it
>> appears at the root of the working tree, without requiring a separate build step,
>> symlink, or copy operation.
>>
>> I understand there are alternative approaches (subtrees, packages, external
>> tooling), but they all involve extra indirection. Having first-class support within Git
>> for this use case would make it much simpler and more consistent.
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>> Thank you for your work maintaining and evolving Git! I would greatly appreciate
>> any feedback on whether this idea has been considered before, and if there are
>> technical reasons it may not fit Git’s model.
>
> I have been thinking about a current use case for this RFE. Consider
> GNU/Configure-based projects where we have config.guess and config.sub in the
> repository root. These two files are independent of the project itself and truly
> should be shared and managed from a single authoritative source. It can be a
> real delay/pain to wait for the project to manually update these two files
> from an upstream to get platform support for their project.
>
> In order to support something like this, we might need a submodule concept
> That supports something like a link upwards. Or this might be something
> That could be part of the sparse-checkout infrastructure. I'm not sure, but I
> Do think there is merit to this. It could also apply to organisations that have
> cross-application root certificates that need to be in the same directory
> as the application root.
Sparse-checkout made me think of some kind of “repository overlay”: as long as there are no conflicts (or perhaps for later versions, conflicts are resolved by higher-layers-win), each layer (i.e., repository) knows only about its own files.
Adding untracked files would need some work to choose a layer.
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 4+ messages in thread
end of thread, other threads:[~2025-09-29 21:17 UTC | newest]
Thread overview: 4+ messages (download: mbox.gz follow: Atom feed
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
2025-09-26 8:33 [Feature Request] Support for sharing root-level files across repositories George Ogden
2025-09-29 17:25 ` rsbecker
2025-09-29 19:32 ` George Ogden
2025-09-29 21:17 ` Ben Knoble
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox